Friday 8 May 2015

New beginning in India Bangladesh relation: Land Boundary Pact a reality, Teesta water treaty soon

Pratim Ranjan Bose

In a rare show of political consensus; the Constitution (119th Amendment) Bill on LBA, was cleared unanimously in both the houses of Indian Parliament on May 6 and May 7. The Bill will now be sent for formal assent of the President.
The consensus was necessary because the Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi’s BJP that has a brute majority in the lower house or Lok Sabha (Assembly of the People) is a minority in the upper house or Rajya Sabha (Council of States).
Forty-one years since the LBA pact was inked in 1974 and, two and a half years after the former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh (2004-2014) entered a pact to ratify the 1974 treaty; India and Bangladesh will bury border disputes, a legacy of the hasty Partition in 1947.
A total of 162 enclaves - some small parcels of land, far detached from the mainland and located inside the foreign territories - of either country will be swapped bringing an end to the human tragedy. Over 51,000 people will be getting national identities.  
There will be no “adversely possessed land” (APL) – disputed land parcels on the international border held by India and Bangladesh in deviation from the Radcliffe line – in the books of either country. The 4000 km long border on the East of India, will henceforth be clearly demarcated and fenced.

Teesta pact on course

It’s a momentous occasion in the history of the subcontinent.
It will probably be even more momentous if the Narendra Modi government finds a clue to solve the Teesta water dispute, before his expected visit to Dhaka in June – exactly a year after Modi’s foreign minister Sushma Swaraj called on the Bangladeshi Prime Minister Seikh Hasina.
progress in convincing the West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee to give up her stubborn resistance to the water-sharing treaty.
Banerjee who had been once been a staunch opponent to Modi (so much so that she had avoided exchanging the due courtesies after Modi became the Prime Minister) is now on sticky wicket - due to corruption charges against her party MPs, MLAs and even ministers - and, is evidently trying to bridge the gap.
Her Trinamool Congress has offered key support to the Narendra Modi government in clearing major Bills (like enhancing FDI cap in insurance, coal sector privatisation and so on) throughout the ongoing Budget Session of the Parliament.
And, that’s not all. The two leaders will spend a lot of time together when the Prime Minister will be visiting Kolkata on May 9 and 10. I guess Teesta pact will feature in their menu.

Bailing Hasina government out

Interestingly, some observers of Hasina camp in Dhaka, having key knowledge of Teesta issues, feel the water sharing pact may not bring any significant material gain to Bangladesh. This is due to issues that are not in control of either government.  
India is currently releasing water based on an old convention, drawn on dated hydrological data on availability of water. But, the climate change and environmental degradation in the catchment area of the river has taken a toll on the availability of water in Teesta in the last two decades.
The fresh hydrological study launched by Delhi will ascertain this truth. And, any agreement to offer Dhaka a higher share of water (from the available quantities) may not necessarily increase the actual flow of water to Bangladesh. Understandably this is also reason why Mamata Banerjee gave up her opposition to the deal.
Her arch rival Khaleda Zia’s BNP boycotted the election in protest against the ban imposed by Hasina government on BNP’s Islamic fundamentalist allies who had been on rampage ever since the Hasina government went ahead with the long pending trial of the 1971 civil war criminals
Hasina was surely right in her decision to clampdown on Islamic hardliners who had long been working at the behest of their Pakistani masters in pursuing a hate campaign against India and spoil every move to improve bilateral ties.
But, there are wide spread allegations against her party for involvement in corruption and nepotism. Also the weak democratic institutional capabilities of the country came in the way of holding the opposition-less election in a free and fair manner.
The most difficult part was the international community led by the US took a middle path and were keen to force Hasina stop the trial of 1971 criminals and, come to terms with Zia for what they refer as a recipe of ‘peace and harmony in the subcontinent’. They were in the mood to declare her re-election as illegal.
Hasina couldn't have survived this pressure, unless India stood by her. The Manmohan Singh government took a decisive stance in convincing the US to not meddle with the Bangladesh’s domestic politics.

Modi diplomacy wins

Having done so, India was morally bound to extend a political weapon to Hasina government to soothe the anti-India nerves in Dhaka. But, it had to be done with caution so that any future change in political equation in Dhaka does not destabilise the economic and political relations between the neighbours.
The Narendra Modi government accomplished it in style.
It is told that the first calls that Modi received from Bangladesh after taking oath in May 2014, was from Khaleda Zia of BNP.
Many in Indian politics are of the opinion that while building political consensus for LBA and Teesta water sharing pact over the last one year; Modi government allowed the dust in Bangladesh’s domestic politics to settle down.
The challenge was to let the deal be debated in Bangladesh as well, so that anti-India forces do not find a conspiracy theory behind and start raising fresh demands at opportune moments.
Modi lived up to the expectation.


***
Tweet: @pratimbose
(Disclaimer: Graphics are collected from the web. Will be removed in case of any objection.) 

No comments:

Post a Comment